• LinkedIn
  • Home
    • Upcoming Events
    • Those Behind
    • Community
    • Submission Guidelines
    • Resources
    • Terms of Service
    • Editor-in-Chief
    • Senior Editorial Consultant
    • Platform
    • Legal Advisory
  • Advertisements
  • Instagram

Whose Deity Is It Anyway? Sacred Art, Fashion, And The Limits Of Intellectual Property Law

This article is authored by Rinchen Nidrol, second-year B.A. LL.B. (Hons.) student at the National Law University, Odisha.

In 2020, couturier Guo Pei sent a gown down the runway embroidered with the unmistakable composition of a thangka, the painted scroll on which Tibetan Buddhists render deities and mandalas for worship.[1,2] Critics, including Tibetan commentators, objected that a thangka is a devotional object, not something to be worn or trailed across a floor. Contemporaneous reports recorded no public response from Guo Pei.[1,2] A decade earlier, in 2010, canvas sneakers carrying the Keds name and printed with images of the Buddha and the Dalai Lama appeared on Zazzle.com, a print-on-demand site, and Tibetan and Buddhist commentators objected that sacred imagery should not be worn on the feet.[3,4] Keds said it had not designed the styles, apologised, and reported that the shoes were no longer for sale there.[5,6] No court or regulator in the jurisdictions concerned (France and China for Guo Pei’s collection, the United States for Keds) is reported to have found either company in breach of any law; the sources cited here record public criticism and, in Keds’s case, an apology, not legal findings.[7] That is the uncomfortable centre of this piece.

Sacred Tibetan iconography, thangka compositions, wrathful protectors like Mahakala, the mantra Om Mani Padme Hum, has become a recurring visual resource for global fashion, deployed as texture or spiritual accessory. Each time, the same objection surfaces online: this belongs to us. And each time it goes nowhere, because no Tibetan monastery, diaspora community, or lineage of painters can assert an enforceable property right over the imagery. The law was never built to answer the question these communities are asking: to whom does this belong?

The Gap Copyright Cannot Fill

Copyright protects original expression fixed by an identifiable author, for a limited term. Classical thangka iconography fails this test in almost every particular. The compositions were codified centuries ago, transmitted through monastic lineages according to proportional grids set out in Tibetan and Indian Buddhist texts. There is no single author, no fixed date of creation, and the underlying vocabulary has long been in the public domain. A contemporary painter holds copyright in the brushwork of their own painting; nobody holds copyright in the idea of Tara seated in her characteristic posture, since copyright does not protect forms standard within a tradition.

This is not a loophole; it is copyright working as designed, for a purpose unconnected to protecting the sacred. The system assumes an author seeking a temporary monopoly in exchange for disclosure. It has no concept of a community seeking the opposite: perpetual, non-commercial custodianship of something it never intended to sell.

Trademark Does Something Almost Worse

Trademark law does not require original authorship at all; it rewards distinctiveness acquired through use. A sign, however old or communally sourced, can become exclusive commercial property once a party uses it consistently enough that consumers associate it with them.

This mechanism is on display in a dispute that convulsed Chinese social media through the summer of 2026. In a first-instance judgment dated 29 June 2026 (some reports give 1 or 2 July), the Suzhou Intermediate People’s Court ordered Molly Tea, a bubble-tea chain, to pay Louis Vuitton RMB 10.3 million (roughly US$1.5 million), made up of RMB 10 million in damages and RMB 300,000 in enforcement costs, after finding that its four-petal flower logo infringed seven of LV’s registered trademarks; Molly Tea has said it will appeal.[8–10] The reasoned judgment has not been officially published, so these details rest on reports of its operative part.[9,10] Louis Vuitton calls its monogram, designed in 1896, a “universal symbol of creativity,” and LVMH attributes it to neo-Gothic ornamentation and Japonist influence. Chinese commentators produced side-by-side images of the pattern against far older floral motifs, asking why a French company using the design since 1896 gets to sue over it. One wire-service headline framed the debate as one about copyright, but the judgment concerned registered trademarks, not copyright.[11] Earlier in 2026, a now-shuttered Nanjing restaurant had been ordered to pay RMB 60,000 in damages and RMB 20,000 in legal fees after a court found that its vintage floral décor infringed Louis Vuitton trademarks.[12]

Legally, Louis Vuitton is almost certainly on solid ground, which is precisely the point. Trademark doctrine, including India’s, does not ask who invented a design; it asks whether the design has become distinctive of a particular source in consumers’ minds. A motif can be a thousand years old and still be “owned,” in the narrow sense trademark law cares about, by whichever commercial actor arrived first with money and litigation budgets sufficient to defend that association. Origin is largely irrelevant to that inquiry; capital and registration do most of the work.

Run that logic forward, and the implication for Tibetan sacred imagery is not hypothetical. Nothing in the core logic of trademark law would stop a fashion house from registering a stylised mandala as its house pattern, building that association over a few seasons, and then sending cease-and-desist letters to smaller producers, including Himalayan artisans using the same vocabulary their communities have used for generations, if those artisans never registered anything. The community with the deepest historical claim would have the weakest paper trail, precisely because sacred art was never made with registries in mind.

Indian law answers part of that scenario, though only part. Section 9(2)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1999 bars registration of a mark that contains or comprises any matter likely to hurt the religious susceptibilities of any class or section of the citizens of India, and a mandala or a deity’s face used as a house pattern is a plausible target, though the test is likelihood of hurt, which turns on the particular mark and its use. Section 11(10)(ii) directs the Registrar, in examination and in opposition, to take into account the bad faith of an applicant or an opponent, which gives a community a way to argue that an application was filed to capture imagery the applicant knew was not its own. Those arguments can be raised in opposition under Section 21, within four months of the application’s advertisement; a registration that slips through remains open to rectification under Section 57 on application by a person aggrieved; and Section 27(2), read with Section 11(3)(a), preserves passing off as a ground of action and of refusal. Section 34 adds that a registered proprietor cannot restrain a continuous prior user of an identical or nearly resembling mark, which could shelter artisans who have long used a motif as a mark. Each counterweight is narrow. Section 9(2)(b) is a bar on registration, not a right in the image, and it works only through the susceptibilities of Indian citizens, such as Himalayan Buddhist communities in India. Opposition depends on someone watching the Trade Marks Journal within the opposition period. Bad faith has to be proved, passing off requires goodwill in trade, which a devotional community will seldom have, and Section 34 protects only the prior user’s own continued use, not a right to exclude others.[13]

Geographical Indications: Closer, But Not Built for This

Geographical indications run into a related but distinct wall. GI protection ties a right to a place and a community of producers rather than a single company, exactly the collective structure Tibetan communities would need. But GI law protects goods whose quality or reputation is attributable to geographic origin: Darjeeling tea, Champagne, Pashmina. It is built for products, not iconography, and cannot easily stretch to cover a deity’s image, since that is not a good tied to terroir. India’s GI Act, 1999 was never drafted to reach it.[14]

The Instrument Still “Coming Soon”

WIPO’s Intergovernmental Committee on Intellectual Property and Genetic Resources, Traditional Knowledge and Folklore has negotiated towards an international legal instrument on traditional cultural expressions since the Committee was established in 2000.[15] A treaty on genetic resources and associated traditional knowledge finally emerged from that process in May 2024,[16,17] but the parallel track on traditional cultural expressions, the one that would address sacred imagery and ritual designs, remains unresolved after roughly a quarter century. As of October 2026 no instrument has been adopted. At its 53rd session in September 2026 the Committee agreed modifications to the draft texts on traditional knowledge and traditional cultural expressions, including a new formulation of objectives, and decided to continue text-based negotiations on the modified texts at its next session;[18,19] commentators describe this as movement past a long textual standstill, with attention now turning to the 2027 WIPO Assemblies.[19] Member states have disagreed on whether protection should be perpetual or term-limited, and on who counts as a beneficiary when no single government represents a community internationally.[20,21] Tibetan communities present the hardest version of this problem, since the community asserting the claim and the state exercising sovereignty over the territory are not the same actor.

What Follows From Taking the Question Seriously

None of this argues that fashion brands must never touch sacred imagery, or that copyright and trademark are illegitimate. It argues that the current architecture answers “to whom does something cultural belong” by default, in favour of whoever moves first with a lawyer and a registration fee, a default unconnected to the intuition doing the real work in these controversies: that a community which has maintained and worshipped through an image for centuries has a claim on it that a brand discovering it for one collection does not.

A more honest architecture would borrow from tools that already exist. India’s Traditional Knowledge Digital Library defensively documents medicinal knowledge so patent examiners abroad can reject applications restating it.[22] That model could be adapted into a documentation registry for sacred iconography, making prior communal use a matter of record that trademark examiners must search before granting rights over a motif. New Zealand’s Haka Ka Mate Attribution Act 2014, recognising Ka Mate as a taonga of Ngāti Toa Rangatira and a haka composed by their chief Te Rauparaha, gives the iwi a right of attribution rather than a right to control use.[23] A publication of Ka Mate for commercial purposes, a communication of it to the public, and a film that includes it and is shown or issued to the public must carry a clear and reasonably prominent statement that Te Rauparaha was its composer and a chief of Ngāti Toa Rangatira. Performances, educational uses, and works made for criticism, review or reporting current events are excluded; the right is subject to any written waiver or agreement given by the iwi’s rights representative; and it is enforceable only by that representative, through a declaratory judgment. There is no consent requirement or royalty, and the Act does not let the iwi stop offensive use, so the haka is not converted into ordinary private property. The Act records the Crown’s acknowledgement of Ngāti Toa Rangatira’s role as kaitiaki, or guardians, but the duty on users is limited to attributing Te Rauparaha as composer and chief.[23] A right of this kind, acknowledgment vested in a custodial body, sitting alongside but distinct from ordinary IP, is closer to what the Tibetan case needs than either copyright’s monopoly or trademark’s registration race.

Until such an instrument exists, the honest answer to who owns a deity’s image is, in most commercial settings, whoever files first, subject to narrow counterweights such as Section 9(2)(b) of India’s Trade Marks Act 1999, bad-faith objections and passing off.[13] That answer will keep producing the same headline, with the names and the motif changed, for as long as the law confuses distinctiveness in commerce with the far older question of who a sacred image belongs to.


References

1. ‘Chinese Fashion Designer Sparks Outrage After “Appropriating” Sacred Tibetan Art’ (NextShark, 3 March 2020) <https://nextshark.com/guo-pei-thangka-tibetan-art-appropriation&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

2. Dickyi T, ‘Chinese Fashion Designer Sparks Outrage After Appropriating Thangka Art’ (Phayul, 4 March 2020) <http://www.phayul.com/2020/03/04/42805/&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

3. Sonam B D, ‘Unholy Shoes’ (Phayul, 17 June 2010) <https://www.phayul.com/?p=27509&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

4. ‘Keds to Promote New Line of “Tibetan Buddhist Shoes”?’ (Tricycle, 17 June 2010) <https://tricycle.org/article/keds-promote-new-line-tibetan-buddhist-shoes/&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

5. ‘Keds Response: “UnHoly Shoes”’ (Phayul, 19 June 2010) <http://www.phayul.com/news/article.aspx?id=27530&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

6. ‘(Mis)using Buddhist Imagery in Advertising’ (The Lost Yak, 27 August 2014) <https://thelostyak.com/2014/08/27/buddhist-imagery-in-advertising/&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

7. ‘Guo Pei Couture Spring 2020’ (WWD) <https://wwd.com/runway/spring-couture-2020/paris/guo-pei/review/&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

8. Louis Vuitton Malletier v Shenzhen Molly Tea Catering Management Co Ltd and another (Suzhou Intermediate People’s Court, (2025) Su 05 Min Chu No 617) (first instance; dated 29 June 2026 according to some reports and 1 or 2 July 2026 according to others; reasoned judgment not officially published)

9. Du Y, ‘China Trademark Law: Louis Vuitton v. Molly Tea – The RMB 10.3 Million Four-Petal Logo Dispute’ (MMLC Group, 15 July 2026) <https://mmlcgroup.com/china-lv-26/&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

10. Wininger A, ‘Louis Vuitton Scores 10 Million RMB in a Controversial Trademark Infringement Dispute Against Molly Tea’ (China IP Law Update, 7 July 2026) <https://chinaiplawupdate.com/2026/07/louis-vuitton-scores-10-million-rmb-in-trademark-infringement-dispute-against-molly-tea/&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

11. Chan H, ‘Louis Vuitton Court Victory Against Chinese Tea Chain Stirs Up a Debate Over Copyrights’ (Associated Press, via BNN Bloomberg, 7 July 2026) <https://www.bnnbloomberg.ca/business/international/2026/07/07/louis-vuitton-court-victory-against-chinese-tea-chain-stirs-up-a-debate-over-copyrights/&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

12. McCartney M, ‘Louis Vuitton Trademark Victory in China Sparks Backlash’ (Newsweek, 7 July 2026) <https://www.newsweek.com/louis-vuitton-court-win-china-backlash-12165937&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

13. Trade Marks Act 1999 (India), ss 9(2)(b), 11(3)(a), 11(10)(ii), 21, 27(2), 34, 57 (as on 1 June 2026) <https://www.indiacode.nic.in/bitstream/123456789/1993/1/a199947.pdf&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

14. Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act 1999 (India), s 2(1)(e) (as on 1 June 2026) <https://www.indiacode.nic.in/bitstream/123456789/1981/1/a199948.pdf&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

15. Alves A do V, ‘ESIL Reflection – WIPO’s New Treaty on Intellectual Property, Genetic Resources and Traditional Knowledge: A Turning Point for Indigenous Heritage?’ (European Society of International Law, 10 October 2024) <https://esil-sedi.eu/?p=39725&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

16. World Intellectual Property Organization, ‘WIPO Member States Adopt Historic New Treaty on Intellectual Property, Genetic Resources and Associated Traditional Knowledge’ (Press Release PR/2024/919, 24 May 2024) <https://www.wipo.int/pressroom/en/articles/2024/article_0007.html&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

17. World Intellectual Property Organization, ‘Summary of the WIPO Treaty on Intellectual Property, Genetic Resources and Associated Traditional Knowledge’ (24 May 2024) <https://www.wipo.int/treaties/en/ip/gratk/summary_gratk.html&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

18. World Intellectual Property Organization, ‘IGC 53 Summary’ (29 September 2026) <https://www.wipo.int/en/web/igc/w/news/2026/igc-53-summary&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

19. Muñoz Tellez V, ‘The WIPO Negotiations on the Protection of Traditional Knowledge and Traditional Cultural Expressions Move Towards Clearer Objectives for the International Instrument’ (SouthViews No 313, South Centre, 1 October 2026) <https://www.southcentre.int/southviews-no-313-1-october-2026/&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

20. Third World Network, ‘WIPO: Attempts to Shift from “Protection” to “Safeguarding” Folklore Criticised’ (TWN Info Service on Biodiversity and Traditional Knowledge, 3 April 2014) <https://twn.my/title2/biotk/2014/btk140403.htm&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

21. ‘Folklife at the International Level: Recent Developments in Protecting Traditional Cultural Expressions’ (Library of Congress, Folklife Today, April 2018) <https://blogs.loc.gov/folklife/2018/04/folklife-at-the-international-level-recent-developments-in-protecting-traditional-cultural-expressions/&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

22. Council of Scientific and Industrial Research, ‘About TKDL’ (Traditional Knowledge Digital Library) <https://www.tkdl.res.in/tkdl/LangDefault/Common/Abouttkdl.asp?GL=Eng&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

23. Haka Ka Mate Attribution Act 2014 (NZ), ss 8–11 <https://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/2014/18/en/latest/&gt; accessed 30 October 2026

Share this:

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
Like Loading…

Fashion Law

Nov 11, 2026
Uncategorized

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Comment
  • Reblog
  • Subscribe Subscribed
    FASHION LAW

    Have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.

  • FASHION LAW
    Copy shortlinkView post in Reader
    Manage subscriptionsSign upLog in
    Report this content
    Collapse this bar
%d